Choosing the right everyday carry (EDC) knife is a deeply personal decision, hinging on individual needs and preferences. This comparison dives deep into two popular choices: the Benchmade 940 Pro Tactical and the Spyderco A300 Ultima Patrol. We'll analyze their strengths and weaknesses to help you determine which blade best suits your style.
Blade Shape and Steel: A Tale of Two Designs
Both knives boast exceptional blade steels, but their shapes differ significantly.
Benchmade 940 Pro Tactical
The 940 Pro features a drop-point blade, renowned for its versatility. The drop-point's gentle curve offers excellent slicing capabilities while maintaining a robust tip for piercing tasks. Benchmade typically uses CPM-S30V steel, a premium stainless steel known for its exceptional edge retention, wear resistance, and corrosion resistance. This makes it a workhorse for various EDC applications.
Spyderco A300 Ultima Patrol
The A300 Ultima Patrol boasts a sheepsfoot blade, characterized by its straight edge and rounded tip. This design excels at slicing and controlled cuts, making it ideal for detailed work or tasks requiring precision. Spyderco utilizes CPM-S30V (often, but variations exist) as well, offering comparable performance in edge retention and durability to the Benchmade.
Handle Ergonomics and Materials: Comfort and Control
The handle design significantly impacts the overall feel and control of the knife.
Benchmade 940 Pro Tactical
The 940 Pro's handle is known for its ergonomic design and comfortable feel. Its sculpted shape and textured grip provide excellent control, even in wet or challenging conditions. The handle usually consists of a lightweight yet durable material, contributing to its overall balance and ease of carry.
Spyderco A300 Ultima Patrol
The A300 Ultima Patrol features a more substantial handle, often crafted from G10 or FRN, providing excellent grip and durability. While potentially slightly heavier than the 940, this design offers enhanced control and stability during extended use. The handle design is geared towards a secure grip, even with gloved hands.
Deployment and Locking Mechanisms: Speed and Safety
Deployment and locking mechanisms are critical for both speed and safety.
Benchmade 940 Pro Tactical
The 940 Pro employs Benchmade's renowned Axis lock, a highly reliable and user-friendly mechanism. The Axis lock allows for one-handed opening and closing with ease, offering both speed and security.
Spyderco A300 Ultima Patrol
The A300 utilizes Spyderco's signature Compression Lock, another highly regarded and robust locking mechanism. Known for its reliability and ease of use, the Compression Lock provides secure blade retention and one-handed operation.
Overall Size and Weight: Portability Considerations
The size and weight impact the practicality of the knife for EDC.
Benchmade 940 Pro Tactical
The 940 Pro is generally smaller and lighter, making it more discreet and comfortable to carry throughout the day. Its compact size doesn't compromise on performance.
Spyderco A300 Ultima Patrol
The A300 is typically larger and heavier than the 940 Pro. While this might feel less discreet, the increased size contributes to enhanced control and stability during use.
Price Point: Investment Considerations
Both knives represent a significant investment, placing them in the higher-end EDC market. Prices fluctuate based on retailer and availability but expect to find both within a similar price range. The specific model and materials can influence the final cost.
Conclusion: The Right Knife for You
Ultimately, the choice between the Benchmade 940 Pro Tactical and the Spyderco A300 Ultima Patrol depends on your priorities. The 940 Pro excels in its lightweight design, comfortable ergonomics, and ease of carry, making it a versatile EDC choice. The A300 Ultima Patrol, on the other hand, offers enhanced control and stability, making it ideal for users who prioritize robust performance and a more substantial feel in their hand. Consider your individual needs and preferences when making your decision. Both are exceptional knives capable of meeting the demands of various EDC scenarios.
